Carnival or MSC: Which Cruise Line is Right for You?
Ready to book your next cruise and the choices are down to Carnival or MSC? Let’s break down the key differences to help you make an informed decision.
A Brief History of MSC Cruises
MSC Cruises boasts a rich maritime heritage, tracing its roots back to the Aponte family’s involvement in seafaring since 1675.
MSC Cruises has been offering cruises from the U.S. since 2013, starting with the Divina. While the company has a long history in the cruise industry, its presence in the North American market is relatively recent. Despite this, MSC Cruises has rapidly expanded its offerings and gained popularity among American cruisers.
To learn more about MSC’s fascinating history, visit their website: [Insert MSC Cruises website [ MSC Cruises ]
A Brief History of Carnival Cruise Line
Carnival Cruise Line, a pioneer in the cruise industry, has been setting sail since 1972.
To learn more about Carnival Cruise Line and its exciting offerings, visit their website:[
Overall Atmosphere
Carnival: Known for its lively, fun-filled atmosphere, Carnival caters to a wide range of ages, with a particular emphasis on families with children. The focus is on creating a fun environment with plenty of activities, entertainment, and dining options to cater to a wide range of tastes.
MSC Cruises: Offers a more sophisticated and international ambiance, appealing to a broader demographic. While family-friendly, MSC also caters to couples and solo travelers seeking a more refined experience.
Cabins
Both cruise lines offer a variety of cabin options, from interior to balcony staterooms and suites. While there might be slight differences in decor and amenities, the overall comfort level is comparable.
Dining
Carnival: Offers a wide range of casual dining options, including buffet-style restaurants, 24-hour pizza, and specialty restaurants for an additional fee.
MSC: Provides a mix of casual and upscale dining options, with a stronger emphasis on international cuisine and specialty restaurants.
Comparison of Kids Clubs: Carnival Cruise Line vs. MSC Cruises
| Feature | Carnival Cruise Line: Camp Ocean | MSC Cruises: MSC Kids Club |
|---|---|---|
| Age Groups | Penguins (2-5) | Baby Club (1-3) |
| Stingrays (6-8) | Mini Club (3-6) | |
| Sharks (9-11) | Junior Club (7-11) | |
| Themes and Partnerships | Dr. Seuss at Sea | LEGO® Experience |
| Activities for Youngest Kids | Storytime, arts and crafts | Playtime with Chicco® toys, baby gymnastics |
| Activities for Middle Kids | Science experiments, sports, arts and crafts | LEGO® play areas, arts and crafts, dancing |
| Activities for Oldest Kids | Sports, video gaming, karaoke | Sports tournaments, video games, team games |
| Special Events/Features | Night Owls babysitting (10 PM – 1 AM) | Cooking classes, Doremi Studio for music and dance |
| Green Eggs and Ham Breakfast | Family activities (sports tournaments, game shows) | |
| Special Needs | Accommodations and trained staff | Accommodations and trained staff |
| Family Integration | Occasional family activities | Structured family activities |
Activities and Entertainment
Carnival: Renowned for its high-energy entertainment, water parks, and dedicated kids’ clubs. Lots of free things to do from sun up to sun down.
Free Daytime Activities on a Carnival Cruise
Carnival Cruise Line is known for its fun and energetic atmosphere, offering a wide range of free activities to keep families entertained.
- Water parks: Many Carnival ships boast impressive water parks with slides, splash pads, and pools for all ages.
- Outdoor activities: Enjoy basketball, volleyball, or mini-golf on deck.
- Live entertainment: Catch live music, comedy shows, or game shows throughout the day.
- Pools and hot tubs: Relax and soak up the sun by the pool or unwind in a hot tub.
- Arts and crafts: Participate in creative workshops and activities for all skill levels.
- Trivia and games: Test your knowledge with trivia contests or enjoy classic board games.
These are just a few examples of the many free activities available on a Carnival cruise. With something for everyone, there’s never a dull moment onboard!
MSC: Offers a more diverse range of activities, including cultural enrichment programs, ballroom dancing, and a focus on international entertainment.
Free Daytime Activities on an MSC Cruise
MSC Cruises offers a more European-inspired experience with a focus on relaxation and sophistication. While still providing plenty of fun for families, the atmosphere tends to be slightly quieter than Carnival. Here are some free daytime activities you might find:
- Pools and relaxation areas: MSC ships often feature elegant pool areas with plenty of sun loungers for relaxation.
- Fitness and wellness: Enjoy complimentary fitness classes, such as yoga, Pilates, or Zumba.
- Sports activities: Participate in basketball, volleyball, or other outdoor games.
- Live music: Relax with live music performances throughout the ship.
- Quiet lounges: Escape the hustle and bustle in the ship’s various lounges and libraries.
- Family-friendly activities: Enjoy games, crafts, and entertainment for all ages.
- Deck games: Participate in classic deck games like shuffleboard or bingo.
MSC Cruises offers a more refined experience, but there’s still plenty to keep everyone entertained.
Carnival added cost activities
Carnival Cruise Line offers a variety of paid activities that cater to different interests and ages. Here are some notable ones:
IMAX Theatre
Description: The IMAX Theatre on select Carnival ships provides a state-of-the-art cinematic experience. Guests can enjoy the latest Hollywood blockbusters, as well as IMAX documentaries.
Cost: Tickets for the IMAX Theatre typically range from $12.95 to $14.95 per person.
Experience: The theater boasts a massive screen and immersive sound, offering a unique movie-watching experience at sea.
SkyZone
Description: SkyZone is an indoor trampoline park on Carnival’s Mardi Gras and Carnival Panorama ship. It features trampolines, a climbing wall, and other fun activities for kids and adults.
Cost: Prices vary depending on the session length and type, ranging from $12 to $18 per person.
Experience: This activity provides a fun and energetic environment, perfect for families and those looking to stay active while on vacation.
Bolt Roller Coaster
Description: The Bolt Roller Coaster is the first roller coaster at sea, available on the Mardi Gras and Carnival Celebration ships. Riders control the speed of their vehicle, which can reach up to 40 miles per hour.
Cost: The ride costs around $15 per person for a single ride.
Experience: Bolt offers a thrilling experience with sharp turns, drops, and stunning ocean views. It’s a must-try for adrenaline seekers.
MSC additional cost activities
MSC Cruises also offers a variety of paid activities to enhance the onboard experience for their guests. Here are some of the notable ones:
F1 Simulator
Description: The F1 Simulator allows guests to experience the thrill of Formula 1 racing. It’s a high-tech, realistic racing experience where participants can compete on famous tracks.
Cost: Prices generally range from $9 to $15 per session.
Experience: The simulator provides an immersive racing experience with realistic visuals, sounds, and motion, making it a popular choice for racing enthusiasts.
XD Interactive Cinema
Description: The XD Interactive Cinema is a 4D theater that offers an interactive movie experience. Guests can enjoy short films with special effects like moving seats, wind, and light.
Cost: Tickets usually cost around $8 to $12 per person.
Experience: This activity offers an engaging and fun experience, perfect for families and groups looking for an interactive entertainment option.
Bowling Alley
Description: Select MSC ships feature a bowling alley where guests can enjoy a few frames while at sea. The lanes are full-sized and equipped with the latest technology.
Cost: The cost is typically around $30 per lane per hour.
Experience: Bowling on board is a great way to spend time with friends and family in a fun, casual setting.
VR Maze
Description: The VR Maze offers a virtual reality adventure where guests navigate through a challenging maze using VR technology.
Cost: Prices generally range from $10 to $15 per session.
Experience: This activity provides a unique and immersive experience, combining physical movement with virtual challenges.
Cirque du Soleil at Sea
Description: Available on MSC’s Meraviglia class ships, Cirque du Soleil at Sea offers exclusive shows in a custom-built theater. Guests can enjoy world-class performances with dinner or drinks.
Cost: Ticket prices range from $15 for a show with a cocktail to $35 for a show with dinner.
Experience: performances are breathtaking and combine acrobatics, music, and visual effects, offering a high-end entertainment experience.
To make the most of your MSC cruise without overspending, check out our tips on [how to save money on an MSC cruise]. This guide offers valuable insights and strategies to help you enjoy all that MSC has to offer while staying within your budget.
Shore excursions: MSC Cruises vs. Carnival Cruise Line
MSC Cruises Excurions
- Diverse Destinations: MSC Cruises offers a wide variety of shore excursions that cover destinations in Europe, South America, the Caribbean, and more. Their European excursions are particularly extensive, given their strong presence in the Mediterranean.
- Cultural Focus: MSC shore excursions often emphasize cultural and historical experiences. Guests can expect guided tours of ancient ruins, museums, and UNESCO World Heritage sites, along with local culinary experiences.
- Exclusive Experiences: MSC offers exclusive excursions for their Yacht Club members, providing more personalized and luxurious experiences.
- Eco-Friendly Options: MSC is increasingly incorporating sustainable and eco-friendly excursions, such as visits to nature reserves and eco-parks.
- Technology Integration: MSC uses technology to enhance the excursion booking process, offering detailed descriptions, videos, and virtual tours on their website and app.
Carnival Cruise Line
- Family-Oriented: Carnival’s shore excursions are known for their family-friendly options. They offer a wide range of activities suitable for all ages, including beach outings, water parks, and adventure tours.
- Adventure and Fun: Carnival focuses heavily on fun and adventure. Popular excursions include zip-lining, ATV rides, snorkeling, and swimming with dolphins. They also offer a variety of party and entertainment-focused excursions.
- Affordable Options: Carnival tends to provide a broader range of price points for their excursions, making it easier for budget-conscious travelers to find suitable options.
- Local Experiences: Carnival often partners with local tour operators to provide authentic local experiences, such as cooking classes, cultural performances, and craft workshops.
- Flexible Packages: Carnival offers flexible excursion packages that allow guests to book multiple activities at a discounted rate, providing better value for money.
Excursion Summary
- Focus: MSC Cruises leans more towards cultural, historical, and eco-friendly excursions, while Carnival Cruise Line emphasizes fun, adventure, and family-oriented activities.
- Destinations: MSC has a stronger presence in Europe, particularly the Mediterranean, offering rich cultural excursions. Carnival focuses on the Caribbean, Bahamas, and Mexico, with a variety of adventure and beach activities.
- Pricing: Carnival generally offers more budget-friendly options, whereas MSC provides exclusive and luxury experiences, particularly for Yacht Club members.
Choosing between MSC and Carnival for shore excursions largely depends on your interests and budget. If you’re looking for cultural immersion and eco-friendly options, MSC might be the better choice. If fun, adventure, and family activities are your priorities, Carnival is likely to offer more suitable options.
Comparing Carnival and MSC Demographics
Carnival: Primarily caters to American families with children, offering a fun and casual atmosphere.
MSC Cruises: Appeals to a broader demographic, including families, couples, and solo travelers, with a focus on a more international experience.
Who is more budget friendly? Carnival or MSC?
Carnival: Often offers competitive base fares and inclusive dining options, making it a budget-friendly choice for some.
MSC Cruises: Might have higher base fares but often includes more amenities and offers a wider range of beverage packages.
Carnival and MSC Private Islands
Carnival: Offers three private islands: Half Moon Cay, Princess Cays, and Grand Turk, each providing unique experiences and amenities.
MSC: Currently has one private island, Ocean Cay MSC Marine Reserve, with a focus on sustainability and environmental conservation.
Comparing Carnival and MSC Itineraries from the US
When sailing from the United States, both Carnival Cruise Line and MSC Cruises offer a variety of itineraries to popular destinations. Here’s a comparison of their typical itineraries:
Carnival Cruise Line
- Primary Departure Ports: Miami, Fort Lauderdale, Port Canaveral, Tampa, Galveston, New Orleans, and Long Beach.
- Popular Destinations: Caribbean**: Eastern, Western, and Southern Caribbean itineraries, including ports like Cozumel, Grand Cayman, St. Thomas, and Aruba.
- Bahamas: Frequent short cruises to Nassau, Freeport, and private islands like Half Moon Cay.
- Mexico: Mexican Riviera cruises from Long Beach, with stops in Cabo San Lucas, Puerto Vallarta, and Mazatlán.
- Cruise Lengths: Ranges from 3-day weekend getaways to 14-day extended cruises.
- Unique Features: Carnival offers a wide range of themed cruises, such as Carnival Journeys, which provide longer and more immersive experiences with unique onboard activities and entertainment.
MSC Cruises
- Primary Departure Ports: Miami and Port Canaveral.
- Popular Destinations:
- Caribbean: Similar to Carnival, MSC offers Eastern, Western, and Southern Caribbean itineraries. Key ports include San Juan, St. Maarten, Cozumel, and Ocho Rios.
- Bahamas: Stops at Nassau and their private island, Ocean Cay MSC Marine Reserve, which offers exclusive beach experiences and eco-friendly activities.
- Cruise Lengths: Typically ranges from 3 to 11 nights, with a focus on 7-night cruises.
- Unique Features: MSC’s itineraries often include overnight stays in key ports, allowing for more in-depth exploration. Their private island, Ocean Cay, offers a unique blend of relaxation and eco-tourism.
Key Differences
- Private Island Experience: MSC’s Ocean Cay MSC Marine Reserve offers a more exclusive and eco-friendly experience compared to Carnival’s Half Moon Cay and Princess Cays.
- Port Variety: While both lines visit many of the same Caribbean and Bahamian ports, MSC tends to include more varied and less frequently visited destinations on some itineraries.
- Length and Theme**: Carnival offers a broader range of cruise lengths and themed cruises, providing more options for different vacation styles and durations.
- Onboard Experience: MSC often includes more overnight stays in ports, allowing for extended exploration, whereas Carnival focuses more on a variety of shorter, action-packed excursions.
Personal Experience with Carnival and MSC
While both Carnival and MSC offer enjoyable experiences, personal preferences play a significant role. One traveler shared their experience of enjoying MSC’s elegant atmosphere and Broadway-style shows, while appreciating Carnival’s diverse dining options and lively atmosphere.
Ultimately, the best cruise line for you depends on your family’s preferences and priorities. Consider factors such as budget, desired activities, and the overall atmosphere you seek when making your decision.
Comparing Loyalty Programs: Carnival Cruise Line vs. MSC Cruises
Carnival Cruise Line and MSC Cruises offer loyalty programs designed to reward repeat cruisers with various benefits. Here’s a comparison of their loyalty programs:
Carnival Cruise Line: VIFP Club (Very Important Fun Person)
Tiers and Benefits (subject to change)
1. Blue (First Sailing)
Benefits: None specific to the tier.
2. Red (2-24 Points)
Benefits: Members-only offers, e-newsletter, and a complimentary 1-liter bottle of water.
3. Gold (25-74 Points)
Benefits: All Red-tier benefits plus a Gold VIFP pin and an invitation to a VIFP party on 5+ day cruises with complimentary drinks and appetizers.
4. Platinum (75-199 Points)
Benefits: All Gold-tier benefits plus priority check-in and boarding, priority spa reservations, priority dining reservations, priority tender boarding, a dedicated phone line, a Platinum VIFP pin, and complimentary wash and fold laundry service.
5. Diamond (200+ Points)
Benefits: All Platinum-tier benefits plus guaranteed dining times, priority seating at shows, unlimited complimentary wash and fold laundry service, a Diamond VIFP pin, special event invitations, a dedicated onboard guest services phone number, a complimentary meal at a specialty restaurant, and a one-time complimentary cabin upgrade or third/fourth guest sail free offer.
Earning Points
How to Earn: Members earn one point for each day sailed with Carnival.
MSC Cruises: MSC Voyagers Club
Tiers and Benefits (Subject to change)
1. Welcome (First Sailing)
Benefits: None specific to the tier.
2. Classic (1-2,199 Points)
Benefits: 5% discount on future cruises, e-newsletter, and members-only offers.
3. Silver (2,200-4,299 Points)
Benefits: All Classic-tier benefits plus priority boarding, a complimentary gift, and a welcome-back cocktail.
4. Gold (4,300-9,999 Points)
Benefits: All Silver-tier benefits plus a complimentary photo, a fruit basket, priority dining reservations, and a free one-hour thermal area session (on ships with MSC Aurea Spa).
5. Diamond (10,000+ Points)
– Benefits: All Gold-tier benefits plus priority disembarkation, a free dance class, a complimentary dinner for two at a specialty restaurant, a free one-hour thermal area session every cruise day, and a Diamond-tier welcome back cocktail.
Earning Points
How to Earn: Points are earned based on the cruise experience booked:
- Bella Experience: 100 points per night.
- Fantastica Experience: 150 points per night.
- Aurea Experience: 200 points per night.
- MSC Yacht Club**: 300 points per night.
– Members also earn points for onboard spending and pre-booked services.
Loyalty Match
Description: MSC Cruises offers a unique loyalty match program, allowing new members to match their status from another cruise line or hotel loyalty program. This enables guests to start at a higher tier in the MSC Voyagers Club based on their existing loyalty status elsewhere.
Key Differences between Carnival and MSC
- Point Accumulation: Carnival’s VIFP Club is simpler, with one point earned per day of sailing. MSC Voyagers Club offers points based on the type of experience booked, which can accelerate point accumulation for higher-tier bookings.
- Benefits: Carnival offers more extensive benefits for higher-tier members, including complimentary laundry services and guaranteed dining times. MSC focuses on luxury experiences with benefits like thermal area access and specialty dining.
- Tier Progression: MSC’s tier progression can be quicker if booking higher-category experiences, while Carnival’s progression is strictly based on the number of days sailed.
- Special Events: Both programs offer special events and parties for mid-tier and high-tier members, but Carnival’s offerings are more frequent and varied.
- Loyalty Match: MSC’s loyalty match program is a significant advantage for cruisers with existing loyalty status from other cruise lines or hotel brands, enabling them to enjoy benefits immediately.
What do cruisers have to say about Carnival and MSC
Tanya H.
Our kids loved the water park on Carnival! They spent hours splashing around and racing down the slides. The Dr Seuss meet-and-greets were also a huge hit, and the kids couldn’t stop talking about it
Sofia S.
We loved the elegant ambiance of the MSC ship. The adults-only pool area was a perfect escape from the crowds. The dining options were also more upscale, offering a refined culinary experience. The seafood was amazing!
Tim J.
The kids’ club on Carnival was a lifesaver! It gave us some much-needed adult time while the kids were having a blast with other children. The variety of activities kept them entertained for hours
Sylvia S.
I enjoyed the lively atmosphere of Carnival. The deck parties with music and dancing were a great way to meet new people. I also appreciated the casual dress code, which made me feel more relaxed.”
Eme & Dan C.
We enjoyed the romantic atmosphere on our MSC cruise. The spa treatments were incredibly relaxing, and we appreciated the quieter atmosphere compared to Carnival. The evening entertainment was also more sophisticated.
Matty J.
While MSC offered some family-friendly activities, we found the overall atmosphere a bit quieter than Carnival. The ship was beautiful, but we missed the high-energy entertainment options for the kids.
Alex & Ben
We had a fantastic time on our Carnival cruise! The atmosphere was incredibly inclusive, and we felt welcomed and comfortable. The entertainment was top-notch, and we enjoyed the variety of dining options. We’d consider another Carnival cruise.
Ana R.
I was worried about finding activities for my teenage daughters, but Carnival exceeded my expectations. They loved the water park, the dance parties, and even the spa treatments. It was a great bonding experience for us, and I appreciated the adult-only areas for some downtime.
Jessie R.
Carnival was perfect for our multigenerational family vacation. The kids were entertained for hours at the water park, while the adults enjoyed the pool and live shows. There was something for everyone. Plus, the dining options were diverse, catering to everyone’s taste
Tom H.
My son loved the water park and the arcade on Carnival. It was great to see him so happy. My mom enjoyed the live shows,Bingo, and the comfortable lounges. While I would have preferred a few more adult-only options, overall it was a fantastic family vacation
Still undecided between a Carnival or MSC cruise?
Let us help you choose! Share your ideal vacation style in the comments, and we’ll recommend the perfect cruise line for you.
Ready to book your dream getaway? Check out our latest cruise deals and start planning your adventure today!
Conclusion
Choosing between Carnival and MSC Cruises ultimately depends on your personal preferences and the desires of your travel companions. Both cruise lines offer exceptional experiences, each with its unique charm and appeal. Whether you’re seeking a vibrant, family-friendly atmosphere or a more refined and sophisticated vacation, you’re sure to create unforgettable memories aboard either Carnival or MSC.
Remember, the best way to decide is to explore specific itineraries, compare amenities, and read reviews from other passengers. Ultimately, both Carnival and MSC have something special to offer, ensuring a fantastic cruise vacation for everyone.
Carnival vs. MSC Cruises FAQs
- What is the biggest difference between Carnival and MSC Cruises?
- Carnival is known for its lively atmosphere and family-friendly activities, while MSC offers a more refined and European-inspired experience.
- Which cruise line is better for families with young children?
- Carnival generally offers more activities and entertainment specifically designed for young children, making it a popular choice for families.
- Which cruise line is better for couples?
- Both Carnival and MSC offer romantic options, but MSC often has a more upscale and intimate atmosphere, making it a popular choice for couples.
- Are there any age restrictions for children on Carnival or MSC cruises?
- Both Carnival and MSC Cruises welcome families with children of all ages. However, there might be specific age requirements for certain activities or amenities.
- What is the dress code like on Carnival and MSC cruises?
- Both Carnival and MSC have relaxed their dress codes in recent years. While there might be specific dress codes for certain restaurants or formal events, casual attire is generally acceptable for most onboard areas.
- Which cruise line has better entertainment options?
- Carnival is known for its lively entertainment, including shows, games, and parties. MSC offers a more refined entertainment experience with a focus on live music and theater productions.
- Are there any adult-only areas on Carnival and MSC cruises?
- Both cruise lines offer adult-only areas, such as pools, lounges, and spas, providing a quiet escape for passengers.
- Which cruise line is better for solo travelers?
- Carnival’s lively atmosphere and numerous activities can be appealing to solo travelers, but MSC also offers opportunities to socialize and explore.
- How do the dining options compare between Carnival and MSC?
- Carnival offers a variety of dining options, including buffet-style, casual, and specialty restaurants. MSC often focuses on a more refined dining experience with a wider selection of gourmet restaurants.
- Which cruise line is more likely to offer itineraries to specific destinations?
- Both Carnival and MSC offer a wide range of itineraries, but it’s worth comparing specific destinations and departure dates to find the best options for your desired vacation.